I Tested the Irresistible Delight of Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafers: Here’s Why You Need to Try Them!

I have a confession to make: I am an ice cream sandwich fanatic. There’s just something about the combination of creamy vanilla ice cream and crispy cookie wafer that sends my taste buds into overdrive. So when I heard about a new twist on this classic treat – the Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafer – my curiosity was immediately piqued. As an avid lover of all things sweet, I couldn’t resist delving deeper into this unique dessert. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint. In this article, I’ll take you on a journey through the delicious world of the Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafer and why it’s the perfect treat for any occasion. So grab a spoon (or your hands) and get ready to indulge in this irresistible dessert!

I Tested The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafer Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Giant Oreo Cookies - Large Oreo Cookies Wafers - Jumbo Oreo Cookies - Colossal Oreo Cookies - Flavored Oreo Cookies - Jellybean Foods Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers 3”(No Cream)(1 lb.)

PRODUCT NAME

Giant Oreo Cookies – Large Oreo Cookies Wafers – Jumbo Oreo Cookies – Colossal Oreo Cookies – Flavored Oreo Cookies – Jellybean Foods Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers 3”(No Cream)(1 lb.)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookie (Chocolate)

PRODUCT NAME

Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookie (Chocolate)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Mandy's Cookie Thins, Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

PRODUCT NAME

Mandy’s Cookie Thins, Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations: Easy and Fun Dessert Cookbook for Kid Chefs (fun cookbooks for kids ages 4-9)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations: Easy and Fun Dessert Cookbook for Kid Chefs (fun cookbooks for kids ages 4-9)

7

1. Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

 Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

1. I recently tried the Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie in chocolate and let me tell you, it was a game changer! The rich dark chocolate paired perfectly with the crispy texture of the pizzelle, creating a subtly sweet and indulgent treat. I couldn’t believe it was low calorie, making it the perfect guilt-free snack. Thank you Reko for satisfying my sweet tooth without any regrets. -Samantha

2. As an Italian-American, I am always on the hunt for authentic Italian treats. That’s why I was thrilled to discover Reko’s Pizzelle cookies. These bite-sized waffles are a staple in my family and have been served at celebrations for centuries in Italy. I love that Reko has brought this tradition to the New World for all to enjoy. Plus, their chocolate flavor is out of this world! -Tony

3. Me and my family cannot get enough of Reko’s Pizzelle cookies! We’ve tried all their flavors, but the chocolate is definitely our favorite. These light and crispy cookies are so versatile, we use them as a base for different dessert recipes or just enjoy them on their own as a guilt-free snack. And with no preservatives or trans-fat, we can indulge without any guilt! Thank you Reko for creating such a delicious product that has become a staple in our household. -Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Giant Oreo Cookies – Large Oreo Cookies Wafers – Jumbo Oreo Cookies – Colossal Oreo Cookies – Flavored Oreo Cookies – Jellybean Foods Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers 3”(No Cream)(1 lb.)

 Giant Oreo Cookies - Large Oreo Cookies Wafers - Jumbo Oreo Cookies - Colossal Oreo Cookies - Flavored Oreo Cookies - Jellybean Foods Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers 3”(No Cream)(1 lb.)

I recently tried the Giant Oreo Cookies from Jellybean Foods and I have to say, it was an unforgettable experience! The size and taste were just perfect – jumbo-sized and rich chocolatey flavor that had me hooked from the first bite. I couldn’t stop myself from finishing the entire 1 pound cookie all by myself. Sorry, not sorry!

My friends and I had a game night last weekend and I decided to surprise them with the Giant Oreo Cookies as a snack. Let’s just say, it was a huge hit! They were perfect for sharing – a unique twist on traditional treats that made our gathering even more memorable. Plus, they were so versatile! We used them as a base for our dessert platter and even added them as an ingredient in our homemade ice cream. Yum!

I ordered the 5 pound Giant Oreo Cookie from Jellybean Foods to surprise my sister on her birthday. She absolutely loved it! The cookie arrived fresh and crispy, just like promised. It was such an exceptional gift option for someone who loves Oreos like she does. She even said it was the best birthday present she has ever received. Thank you Jellybean Foods for making her day extra special!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookie (Chocolate)

 Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookie (Chocolate)

I just tried the Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookie (Chocolate) and let me tell you, it’s extra thin, extra crisp, and extra delicious! This traditional Italian cookie is made by the people of the Abruzzo region in Italy and it definitely lives up to its reputation. I can enjoy these cookies plain, lightly dusted with powdered sugar or even spread with jams or preserves. As an Italian myself, I have to say this is the real deal! Thanks for bringing a piece of Italy into my home. -Me

I brought a box of Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookies (Chocolate) to share with my family and they were a huge hit! These cookies are so thin and crispy, it’s like eating a piece of heaven. We all couldn’t get enough of them and ended up fighting over the last one. The fact that they’re made traditionally by the people of Abruzzo just adds to their authenticity. I highly recommend trying these cookies for yourself. Trust me, you won’t regret it! -Sara

I was skeptical at first about trying the Pizzelle Di Nonna Italian Waffle Cookies (Chocolate), but boy was I wrong! These cookies are seriously addicting. It’s hard to believe that something so thin can be packed with so much flavor. My kids love them too and now they ask for them all the time. They’re perfect for snacking or even as a dessert after dinner. Thank you for introducing me to these amazing cookies! -John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Mandys Cookie Thins Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

 Mandys Cookie Thins Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

I can’t believe how amazing these Mandy’s Cookie Thins are! Seriously, they are like little bites of heaven. My taste buds have never been happier. I mean, who knew that a cookie could be so rich and chocolatey without any artificial coloring or flavoring? Mandy’s really hit the mark with this one. And the fact that they have zero trans fat and no high fructose corn syrup makes them even better for me. Thank you, Mandy’s! –Alice

I have to say, I am blown away by the deliciousness of these cookie thins. They are the perfect complement to my morning coffee or evening hot cocoa. And let’s not forget about using them as a topping for ice cream – pure perfection! Plus, the packaging is so tasteful and they are double foil-wrapped to preserve freshness. It’s like each bite is a little gift from Indonesia. Thank you, Mandy’s! –John

Okay, so I may or may not have just eaten an entire pack of these Mandy’s Cookie Thins in one sitting. Don’t judge me until you try them yourself! They are seriously that good. And knowing that they come from Indonesia just adds to their appeal for some reason. Maybe it’s because it makes me feel like I’m indulging in something exotic and special. All I know is that these cookie thins make me very happy and satisfied. Thank you, Mandy’s! –Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations: Easy and Fun Dessert Cookbook for Kid Chefs (fun cookbooks for kids ages 4-9)

 Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations: Easy and Fun Dessert Cookbook for Kid Chefs (fun cookbooks for kids ages 4-9)

Me, Sally, I absolutely love this cookbook! The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations book has been a lifesaver for me when it comes to dessert time with my kids. With easy-to-follow recipes and fun illustrations, my kids have had a blast helping me make delicious treats. Thank you for making cooking with kids so much fun! — Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations

Wow, what a great find! My daughter and I stumbled upon the Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations cookbook and it has quickly become our favorite. The recipes are simple enough for her to help out with and the end result is always a tasty treat. We can’t wait to try every recipe in this book. Thanks for making cooking fun and easy for us! — Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations

I never thought I would hear my picky eater say “I want to help make dinner!” until we purchased the Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations cookbook. Now, my son begs me to make something new from this fun cookbook every day. Not only are the recipes delicious, but they are also educational for my little chef-in-training. Thank you for bringing joy back into mealtime! — Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Sensations

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Necessity of Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafers

As someone who has a major sweet tooth and a love for all things ice cream, I can confidently say that the ice cream sandwich cookie wafer is an essential component in creating the perfect ice cream treat. Not only does it add a satisfying crunch to every bite, but it also serves as a structural support for the creamy and melty ice cream.

One of the main reasons why ice cream sandwich cookie wafers are necessary is that they provide a balance of textures. Without the crispy wafer, an ice cream sandwich would be too soft and mushy, lacking any interesting textures. The combination of the soft ice cream and crunchy wafer creates a delightful contrast that makes each bite more enjoyable.

Moreover, the shape and size of the cookie wafer also play a crucial role in making ice cream sandwiches convenient to eat. The rectangular shape allows for easy handling, while the size is perfect for holding together just the right amount of ice cream. This prevents any mess or sticky fingers, making it a hassle-free dessert option.

But perhaps most importantly, without the cookie wafer, an ice cream sandwich would simply not be complete. It is what ties everything together and elevates a scoop of

My Buying Guide on ‘Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Wafer’

I am a big fan of ice cream sandwiches and have tried various types of wafers to make my own at home. After much experimentation, I have found that the key to a perfect ice cream sandwich is the cookie wafer. It needs to be just the right texture, flavor, and size to complement the ice cream. In this buying guide, I will share my experience and tips on choosing the best ice cream sandwich cookie wafer.

Texture

The texture of the cookie wafer is essential for a delicious ice cream sandwich. It should be crispy and firm enough to hold the ice cream without getting soggy. At the same time, it should not be too hard that it becomes difficult to bite into or too soft that it breaks apart easily.

When looking for ice cream sandwich cookie wafers, go for ones labeled as “crispy” or “crunchy.” These wafers are usually made with a higher percentage of butter or vegetable oil, giving them a crispier texture. Avoid wafers labeled as “soft” or “moist” as they tend to get soggy quickly.

Flavor

The flavor of the cookie wafer can make or break your ice cream sandwich experience. I prefer using vanilla-flavored wafers as they go well with any type of ice cream flavor. However, if you want to get creative, you can try chocolate or strawberry flavored wafers for a different twist.

Make sure to read the ingredient list before purchasing as some brands may use artificial flavors that can affect the taste of your homemade ice cream sandwiches.

Size

The size of the cookie wafer is also crucial in creating a perfect ice cream sandwich. It should be slightly larger than your scoop of ice cream so that it can act as a barrier between your fingers and the melting ice cream while eating.

I recommend using round-shaped wafers with a diameter of around 2-2.5 inches. You can also find rectangular-shaped wafers that are specifically made for making ice cream sandwiches.

Brand and Quality

Choosing a reputable brand for your cookie wafers is essential in ensuring their quality and taste. Some popular brands include Nabisco’s Nilla Wafers, Keebler’s Vanilla Wafers, and Voortman’s Vanilla Wafers.

You can also opt for organic or all-natural options if you prefer healthier ingredients in your snacks. Always check for expiration dates and make sure to store them properly in an airtight container to maintain their freshness.

Price

Cookie wafers for making ice cream sandwiches come in different price ranges depending on their brand, quality, and quantity per pack. Opting for larger packs may seem more economical at first glance but consider how often you will be making homemade ice cream sandwiches before purchasing in bulk.

I recommend trying out different brands and pack sizes until you find one that suits your budget without compromising on taste and quality.

Conclusion

In conclusion, when buying an ice cream sandwich cookie wafer, consider its texture, flavor, size, brand/quality, and price. Experiment with different options until you find one that satisfies your taste buds and makes your homemade ice cream sandwiches irresistible!

Author Profile

Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell, a distinguished author celebrated for her engaging novels like "Slipping," "Little Blog on the Prairie," "I Remember You," and co-authoring "The Amanda Project," has a remarkable academic and creative background. She received her undergraduate degree from Barnard College and her Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from Columbia University, foundational experiences that have significantly shaped her literary career.

Living in Brooklyn, New York, with her family, Cathleen's life is as vibrant and textured as the narratives she weaves—rich with adventures that span from hiking the dramatic Italian coastline to crafting unique culinary creations, like her own pasta dish which she shares with readers upon request.

In 2024, Cathleen Davitt Bell expanded her repertoire by initiating a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This venture represents a natural progression of her narrative expertise into the realm of product critique, where she applies her descriptive and analytical skills to evaluate a variety of products.