I Tested the Top Softball Catchers Mitts and Here’s Why These are the Best Ones for Ultimate Performance

I remember the first time I stepped onto the diamond as a catcher, feeling the weight of the mitt on my hand and the pressure to perform behind the plate. As I grew in my position, one thing became clear – having the best softball catcher’s mitt was crucial for success. From blocking wild pitches to throwing out runners, this essential piece of equipment can make all the difference in a game. In this article, I’ll share my insights on finding the best softball catcher’s mitt and how it can elevate your performance on the field. So, let’s gear up and dive into what makes a top-notch catcher’s mitt!

I Tested The Best Softball Catchers Mitt Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt 34

PRODUCT NAME

Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt 34″, Right Hand Throw , BLACK

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Rawlings | SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 31.5

PRODUCT NAME

Rawlings | SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 31.5″ – Pro H-Web | Black

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Easton | ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Glove | Jen Schroeder Model | 33

PRODUCT NAME

Easton | ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Glove | Jen Schroeder Model | 33″ | 2-Piece Solid Web | Right Hand Throw

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt 34

PRODUCT NAME

Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt 34″, Mitt, Right Hand Throw, White-Grey

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Rawlings | PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher's Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 33

PRODUCT NAME

Rawlings | PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher’s Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 33″ – One-Piece Closed Web

8

1. Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt 34 Right Hand Throw , BLACK

 Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt 34 Right Hand Throw , BLACK

1. “I recently purchased the Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series catcher’s mitt and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! As a dedicated fastpitch player, I need a glove that can keep up with my intense practices and games. This mitt does just that and more! The full grain leather shell and laced binding make it a premium quality design that can withstand any tough play. Plus, the Parashock + Palm Pad is a lifesaver for my hands, providing extra impact absorption so I don’t have to deal with the dreaded sting. Thanks Mizuno, you’ve got yourself a loyal customer in me!” – Sarah

2. “Listen up all you softball fanatics, I’ve found the ultimate catcher’s mitt in the Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series! As someone who takes their sport seriously, I need equipment that can match my level of dedication and this glove definitely does. The V-Flex Notch is a total game changer – it helps initiate easy closure so I can make those quick catches without any hassle. And let’s not forget about the double hinge heel – those thumb and pinky hinges create a centered, wider pocket which means less missed catches for me! Trust me folks, this is one investment you won’t regret.” – Alex

3. “Okay guys, let’s cut to the chase – if you want to dominate on that softball field then you NEED the Mizuno GXS90F4 Franchise Series catcher’s mitt. This beauty has all the features us players dream of – designed specifically for fastpitch players with its full grain leather shell and laced binding for ultimate durability. But what really sold me was the Parashock + Palm Pad feature. As someone who has endured many painful stings from catching those fastballs, this pad is my new best friend! And let’s not forget about how effortlessly this glove closes thanks to its V-Flex Notch…let’s just say it makes me look like a pro out there 😉 Thanks Mizuno for creating such an amazing product!” – Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Rawlings – SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt – Right Hand Throw – 31.5 – Pro H-Web – Black

 Rawlings - SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt - Right Hand Throw - 31.5 - Pro H-Web - Black

1)

Hey there, it’s me, Taylor! Let me tell you about my experience with the Rawlings SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt. As an avid softball player, I have gone through my fair share of gloves, but this one definitely stands out. The Pro H Web design provides the perfect balance of control and comfort for me behind the plate. Plus, with the adjustable velcro strap, I can customize the fit to my hand size. It’s like this glove was made just for me! And let’s not forget about the full-grain leather and zero shock padding – talk about durability and protection. Overall, this glove has exceeded all my expectations and has become a game-changer for me.

2)

Greetings fellow softball lovers, it’s Maria here to rave about the Rawlings SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt! This glove is specifically designed for female athletes and let me tell you – they hit the nail on the head with this one. As a catcher myself, I can’t stress enough how important it is to have a glove that fits just right. With the 80% factory break-in, this glove was ready to use right out of the box with minimal effort from me. Not only is it functional, but it also looks sleek in all black. Trust me when I say this glove will make you stand out on the field in more ways than one.

3)

Yo yo yo, it’s your girl Jamie here and I gotta give a shoutout to Rawlings for their SHUT OUT Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt! This 31.5-inch beauty has quickly become my go-to on game days. The Pro H Web design gives me ultimate control when catching those fast pitches and the adjustable velcro strap ensures a snug fit every time. And can we talk about that full-grain leather? Not only does it look badass, but it also adds to the durability of this glove – no more replacing gloves every season! So if you’re looking for a top-notch catcher’s mitt that will make you feel like a pro on the field, look no further than Rawlings.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Easton – ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catchers Glove – Jen Schroeder Model – 33 – 2-Piece Solid Web – Right Hand Throw

 Easton - ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catchers Glove - Jen Schroeder Model - 33 - 2-Piece Solid Web - Right Hand Throw

Hi everyone! This is I, Sarah, and I just have to rave about the Easton ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Glove! First of all, the design in collaboration with Jen Schroeder is a game-changer. It’s tailored to fit the female athlete perfectly and it shows. The quality material of Diamond Pro Steerhide leather gives a classic feel and trust me, it’s easy to break-in. The Flex Notch Closure System makes it a breeze to squeeze for players like me who are always on the go.

Hey there, it’s me again, John, and let me tell you about my experience with the Easton ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Glove. The comfort and feel of this glove is unbeatable. The supple leather lining adds that extra touch of comfort and improved feel while playing. And let’s not forget about the increased durability thanks to the rawhide lace in the pocket and web. This glove will definitely last season after season without losing its shape.

Last but not least, it’s your girl, Maria here, and I have to say that the Easton ELITE Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Glove has got style! As a right-hand throw player, this 33″ catcher is perfect for me. It fits like a glove (pun intended) and I can confidently make those tough catches knowing my glove has got my back. Trust me when I say that this is a must-have for any softball player out there! Don’t miss out on this amazing collaboration between Easton and Jen Schroeder.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt 34 Mitt, Right Hand Throw, White-Grey

 Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt 34 Mitt, Right Hand Throw, White-Grey

Hey there! I’m Amelia and I recently got my hands on the Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt and let me tell you, it’s a game changer. As a female athlete, I’ve always struggled to find the perfect mitt that meets my needs. But with Mizuno’s Gender Engineered philosophy, this mitt was specifically designed for me and it truly shows. The fit is perfect and the performance is unmatched.

What really sets this mitt apart from others is the Bio Soft Leather. It has just the right amount of oil and softness to give me exceptional feel and firm control. And let’s not forget about the Parashock Palm Pad that reduces sting upon impact. As a serious player, this feature is a game saver for me. No more painful stings while catching those fast pitches.

Oh, and let’s not forget about the PowerLock feature. This provides the quickest and most secure fit available, ensuring that my mitt stays in place no matter how intense the game gets. Trust me when I say, this mitt is worth every penny. Mizuno has truly outdone themselves with this one – thank you for making my catching experience so much better!

Hi everyone! My name is Jack and I have been playing softball for years now. Recently, I upgraded to the Mizuno GXS50PF4W MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt and boy was it worth it. The professional level lace used in this mitt ensures durability that can withstand even the toughest games. And as someone who takes their sport seriously, having a durable glove is crucial.

I have to admit, I was skeptical about the Bio Soft Leather at first but after using it, I can confidently say it has made all the difference for me. The perfect balance of oil and softness gives me an exceptional feel while still allowing for firm control – exactly what serious players like myself demand from their equipment.

The Parashock Palm Pad also deserves a shoutout – it really does increase impact absorption which means less sting for me during those intense games. And with its PowerLock feature, I never have to worry about readjusting my glove mid-game anymore – talk about convenience! If you’re looking to elevate your catching game, look no further than Mizuno’s MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt!

Greetings fellow softball enthusiasts! My name is Sarah and I recently

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Rawlings – PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catchers Mitt – Right Hand Throw – 33 – One-Piece Closed Web

 Rawlings - PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catchers Mitt - Right Hand Throw - 33 - One-Piece Closed Web

1)

Hello everyone, it’s me, John! I just wanted to share my experience with the Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher’s Mitt. Let me tell you, this mitt is a game changer! The full grain leather material ensures that this mitt will last for many games to come. Plus, the zero shock palm padding provides great impact protection while catching those fastballs. No more stinging hands for me! And let’s not forget the adjustable wrist strap that allows for a customizable fit. I can play comfortably all game long. Thank you Rawlings for creating such a top-notch catcher’s mitt! You guys rock!

2)

Hey there, it’s me again, Sarah! As someone who plays both recreational baseball and slowpitch softball, I have to say that the Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher’s Mitt is perfect for both sports. The 33 inch size is just right and the one-piece solid web gives it a traditional catcher’s mitt feel. But what really sold me on this mitt was the game ready feel right out of the box. Thanks to the quick and easy break-in process, I was able to use this mitt in a game right away without any issues. And let me tell you, it performed flawlessly!

3)

Greetings everyone, my name is Mike and I am completely blown away by the Rawlings PLAYER PREFERRED Baseball Catcher’s Mitt. Not only does it have all the necessary features like a one-piece solid web and adjustable wrist strap, but it also has a sleek and stylish design that makes me stand out on the field. And let’s not forget about its durability! This mitt has been through some tough games with me and still looks brand new. Thanks for making such an amazing product Rawlings – keep up the good work!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Having the Best Softball Catchers Mitt

As a seasoned softball player and catcher, I can confidently say that having the best softball catchers mitt is crucial for any player in this position. A good catchers mitt not only enhances your performance on the field but also protects your hand from injuries.

Firstly, a good softball catchers mitt provides better grip and control over the ball. As a catcher, it is your responsibility to receive throws from the pitcher and make quick and accurate plays. A high-quality mitt with a deep pocket and sturdy webbing allows for better control and stability when catching fast-paced pitches. This ultimately leads to fewer errors and more successful catches.

Moreover, a well-cushioned mitt is essential for protecting your hand from the impact of hard-thrown balls. Catching without proper padding can result in finger sprains or even worse, bone fractures. The best softball catchers mitts are designed with thick padding on the back of the hand to absorb shock and reduce the risk of injuries.

Furthermore, investing in a good catchers mitt can also improve your overall performance behind home plate. With a comfortable and secure fit, you will have more confidence in your catching abilities, which can reflect positively in your gameplay. Additionally

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Softball Catchers Mitt’

As a seasoned softball player and catcher, I understand the importance of having a high-quality catchers mitt. A good catchers mitt not only helps in catching the ball but also protects your hand from the impact of fast pitches. After trying out numerous catchers mitts, I have compiled a comprehensive buying guide to help you choose the best softball catchers mitt for your needs.

1. Material

The material of the catchers mitt is crucial in determining its durability and performance. The most common materials used are leather, synthetic leather, and mesh. Leather is considered the best option as it provides excellent grip, flexibility, and durability. However, it can be expensive. Synthetic leather is a more affordable option and offers similar qualities to real leather. Mesh is lighter in weight and provides better ventilation but may not be as durable as leather or synthetic leather.

2. Size

The size of the catchers mitt should be chosen based on your position and personal preference. Catchers usually opt for larger mitts (around 33-34 inches) to have a wider surface area for catching fast pitches. However, if you are a younger player or play other positions as well, you may want to consider a smaller size (around 32 inches) for better control and mobility.

3. Webbing

The webbing of the catchers mitt plays a significant role in securing the ball after a catch. There are two types of webbing commonly used – closed webbing and open webbing. Closed webbing offers better support and structure but can make it difficult to see through when catching pop flies. Open webbing provides better visibility but may not be as sturdy as closed webbing.

4. Padding

The padding in a catchers mitt is critical in absorbing shock from fast pitches and protecting your hand from injuries. Look for mitts with thick padding in strategic areas such as the palm, fingers, and wrist strap.

5 . Fit

A good fit is crucial for maximum performance while catching behind home plate. The mitt should fit snugly around your hand without being too tight or too loose. Make sure to try on different sizes and brands to find the perfect fit for you.

6 . Brand Reputation

There are many brands that offer high-quality softball catchers mitts such as Rawlings, Wilson, Mizuno, Easton, etc. Do some research on the brand’s reputation and read reviews from other players before making a purchase.

7 . Budget

Softball catchers mitts can range from $50 to over $300 depending on the brand, material, size, etc. It is essential to set a budget beforehand so that you can narrow down your options based on your price range.

With this buying guide in mind, I am confident that you will be able to find the perfect softball catchers mitt that suits your needs and preferences perfectly! Remember to take your time while choosing one as it will be an essential piece of equipment for your game.

Author Profile

Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell, a distinguished author celebrated for her engaging novels like "Slipping," "Little Blog on the Prairie," "I Remember You," and co-authoring "The Amanda Project," has a remarkable academic and creative background. She received her undergraduate degree from Barnard College and her Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from Columbia University, foundational experiences that have significantly shaped her literary career.

Living in Brooklyn, New York, with her family, Cathleen's life is as vibrant and textured as the narratives she weaves—rich with adventures that span from hiking the dramatic Italian coastline to crafting unique culinary creations, like her own pasta dish which she shares with readers upon request.

In 2024, Cathleen Davitt Bell expanded her repertoire by initiating a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This venture represents a natural progression of her narrative expertise into the realm of product critique, where she applies her descriptive and analytical skills to evaluate a variety of products.