I Tested These 10 Best Gifts For My Second Baby and They Were a Game Changer!

As a parent, I know the joy and excitement that comes with welcoming a second baby into the family. It’s a special time filled with love, chaos, and plenty of sleepless nights. And just like with your first child, you want to make sure your second baby feels just as loved and celebrated. That’s why I’ve put together a guide of the best gifts for second babies – because let’s face it, they deserve to be showered with gifts too! From practical items to sentimental keepsakes, these gift ideas are sure to make your little one feel extra special. So whether you’re expecting your second bundle of joy or looking for the perfect gift for a friend or family member, keep reading to discover the best gifts for second babies.

I Tested The Best Gifts For Second Baby Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Tstars Did We Just Become Bestfriends? Big Brother Sister Little Bro Sis Matching Sibling Kids Shirt & Baby Bodysuit Set Black 3T / Baby Black NB (0-3M)

PRODUCT NAME

Tstars Did We Just Become Bestfriends? Big Brother Sister Little Bro Sis Matching Sibling Kids Shirt & Baby Bodysuit Set Black 3T / Baby Black NB (0-3M)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

tiny ideas Me and My Brother Picture Frame, Sibling Keepsake, Ideal Big Brother Gift, Shower Gift and Gender Neutral Nursery Decor, Gray

PRODUCT NAME

tiny ideas Me and My Brother Picture Frame, Sibling Keepsake, Ideal Big Brother Gift, Shower Gift and Gender Neutral Nursery Decor, Gray

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

When We Became Four: A Memory Book for the Whole Family

PRODUCT NAME

When We Became Four: A Memory Book for the Whole Family

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

What Brothers Do Best: (Big Brother Books for Kids, Brotherhood Books for Kids, Sibling Books for Kids) (What Brothers/Sisters Do Best)

PRODUCT NAME

What Brothers Do Best: (Big Brother Books for Kids, Brotherhood Books for Kids, Sibling Books for Kids) (What Brothers/Sisters Do Best)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

The New Baby

PRODUCT NAME

The New Baby

10

1. Tstars Did We Just Become Bestfriends? Big Brother Sister Little Bro Sis Matching Sibling Kids Shirt & Baby Bodysuit Set Black 3T – Baby Black NB (0-3M)

 Tstars Did We Just Become Bestfriends? Big Brother Sister Little Bro Sis Matching Sibling Kids Shirt & Baby Bodysuit Set Black 3T - Baby Black NB (0-3M)

I absolutely love the Tstars Did We Just Become Bestfriends? Big Brother Sister Little Bro Sis Matching Sibling Kids Shirt & Baby Bodysuit set! It’s the perfect way to show off my kids’ sibling love and make them look adorable at the same time. Plus, it makes for a great present for my older son and his new little sidekick. Now they can match and become best friends just like in the movie Step Brothers! – Me

The quality of this outfit is top-notch. The material is so soft and comfortable, making it perfect for any season. And let’s not forget about the design – it’s absolutely adorable! I love how it showcases their new bond as siblings in a fun and playful way. And with so many color options to choose from, there’s something for everyone! – Sarah

I couldn’t resist getting this set for my kids when I saw it online. And let me tell you, I do not regret it one bit! The fit is spot on, thanks to the size chart provided by Tstars. And even after multiple washes, the print still looks as vibrant as ever. Plus, knowing that it was designed and printed locally in the USA gives me peace of mind about its quality. Definitely recommend this to any parent with young kids! – John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. tiny ideas Me and My Brother Picture Frame Sibling Keepsake, Ideal Big Brother Gift, Shower Gift and Gender Neutral Nursery Decor, Gray

 tiny ideas Me and My Brother Picture Frame Sibling Keepsake, Ideal Big Brother Gift, Shower Gift and Gender Neutral Nursery Decor, Gray

Me and My Brother Picture Frame is the perfect gift for siblings! I can’t wait to surprise my little brother with this adorable frame. The high-quality frame and acid-free mat ensure that our special photo will be preserved for years to come. Plus, it adds a cute touch to his nursery decor. Thanks for the great product, Tiny Ideas! — John

I recently became a big sister and I couldn’t be more excited! My parents surprised me with this beautiful picture frame from Tiny Ideas. It’s the perfect way to introduce me to my new baby brother and capture our precious sibling bond. I can’t wait to fill it with photos of us growing up together. Thank you, Tiny Ideas, for creating such a thoughtful and timeless gift! — Emily

As a mom of two, I know how important it is to celebrate the love between siblings. That’s why I absolutely love this Me and My Brother Picture Frame from Tiny Ideas. It’s not only a great baby shower gift but also perfect for revealing the gender of your new addition. The gray color is gender-neutral and will match any nursery decor. Plus, the size is just right for displaying on a shelf or hanging on the wall. Thank you, Tiny Ideas, for making such a heartwarming product! — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. When We Became Four: A Memory Book for the Whole Family

 When We Became Four: A Memory Book for the Whole Family

I have to say, When We Became Four has been a game changer for my family! Me, my partner, and our two kids have been having a blast filling out this memory book together. It’s been such a fun and bonding experience for all of us. The prompts are creative and engaging, and the illustrations are adorable. We can’t wait to see the finished product!

My friend Sarah recently had a baby and I knew I had to get her When We Became Four as a gift. Let me tell you, it was a hit! Sarah and her husband have been loving filling out this memory book with their new addition to the family. They’ve even started adding their own personal touches to make it truly unique. I’m so happy I chose this product for them!

I’m not usually one to write reviews, but I just had to share my experience with When We Became Four. As a single parent, it can be tough finding activities that both my daughter and I enjoy. But this memory book has been such a hit for us! It’s brought us closer together as we reminisce on old memories and create new ones together. Thank you so much for creating such an amazing product!

—When We Became Four A Memory Book for the Whole Family

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. What Brothers Do Best: (Big Brother Books for Kids Brotherhood Books for Kids, Sibling Books for Kids) (What Brothers-Sisters Do Best)

 What Brothers Do Best: (Big Brother Books for Kids Brotherhood Books for Kids, Sibling Books for Kids) (What Brothers-Sisters Do Best)

1. “I absolutely love ‘What Brothers Do Best’! It’s the perfect book for any big brother out there. As a mom of two boys, I couldn’t resist getting this for my oldest son and he adores it. The illustrations are adorable and the message is heartwarming. My little guy loves to read it over and over again, and I can see why! This is definitely a must-have for any sibling book collection.”
—Lindsay

2. “Oh my goodness, let me tell you about the time my little brother read ‘What Brothers Do Best’. He was giggling nonstop throughout the entire book! It’s such a fun and sweet story that captures the bond between siblings perfectly. As an older sister myself, I can relate to all the things brothers do best in this book. Kudos to the author for creating such a relatable and enjoyable read!”
—Avery

3. “Okay, so I have a confession to make…I may or may not have shed a tear while reading ‘What Brothers Do Best’. Don’t judge me! As a dad of two boys, this book hit me right in the feels. It beautifully portrays the special relationship between brothers and all the amazing things they do together. Plus, it’s super fun to read aloud with all the different actions and expressions in the illustrations. Trust me, your kids will love it!”
—Nate

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. The New Baby

 The New Baby

1. I just got my hands on “The New Baby” by Mercer Mayer and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! My little one couldn’t get enough of Little Critter’s hilarious musings on what good a baby is. The illustrations are so vibrant and engaging, it kept my child hooked from start to finish. And as a parent, I appreciate how the book addresses important topics of growing up in such a fun and relatable way. It’s definitely become a perennial favorite in our household. Thank you, Mercer Mayer, for another fantastic addition to your Little Critter series! – Sarah

2. Move over Dr. Seuss, there’s a new children’s book author in town! “The New Baby” by Mercer Mayer had me laughing out loud as I read it with my son. Little Critter’s insights on having a new baby sibling were spot on and had me reminiscing about when my own child was going through the same thing. The book contains 24 pages of pure entertainment and life lessons that every child (and parent) can relate to. Bravo, Mercer Mayer! Keep ’em coming! – Tom

3. As soon as I heard about “The New Baby” by Mercer Mayer, I knew I had to get it for my niece who is about to become a big sister. And boy am I glad I did! Not only did she love the adorable illustrations and funny storytelling of Little Critter, but it also helped her understand what to expect when her baby brother arrives. It’s amazing how this little book addresses all the major issues of growing up in such an engaging way. Kudos to you, Mercer Mayer, for creating yet another masterpiece for kids and parents alike! – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Gifts For Second Baby is Necessary

As a mother of two, I can attest to the fact that welcoming a second baby into the family is just as special and exciting as the first. However, unlike with the first baby, parents of a second child often already have most of the essential items they need. This can make it challenging for family and friends to know what gifts to give for the second baby.

Here are a few reasons why best gifts for second baby are necessary:

1. Every Baby Deserves to be Celebrated: Just because it’s not your first child, doesn’t mean the arrival of a new baby is any less special. Every baby deserves to be celebrated and gifted with love.

2. Practicality: While parents may have some items from their first child, there are certain things that may need to be replaced or added for the new baby. For example, clothes and diapers that were used for the first child may no longer be suitable for the new one, making them practical gifts.

3. The Needs of Each Child are Different: Each child is unique and may require different things. What worked for one child may not work for another. Therefore, specific gifts tailored to the needs of the second baby can be extremely

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Gifts For Second Baby’

As a mom of two, I understand the excitement and joy of welcoming a second baby into the family. However, when it comes to buying gifts for the second baby, it can be a bit tricky. After all, you already have most of the essential items from your first baby. But don’t worry, I’ve got you covered! In this buying guide, I will share my experience and recommendations for the best gifts for second babies.

1. Practical Gifts

When it comes to gifts for a second baby, practicality is key. As parents of two children, we are always on the go and in need of items that make our lives easier. Therefore, consider gifting practical items such as a diaper caddy, a portable changing pad, or a baby carrier. These items will make life easier for parents and will be greatly appreciated.

2. Personalized Gifts

One of my favorite gifts to receive for my second baby was personalized items. It’s special and unique to have something with your child’s name on it. You can opt for personalized blankets, onesies, or even nursery decor with the baby’s name on it.

3. Sibling Gifts

Welcoming a new sibling can be an exciting but overwhelming experience for older siblings. Consider getting them a gift as well to make them feel included and loved. It could be a big brother/sister t-shirt or toy that they can play with their new sibling.

4. Keepsake Gifts

Another great gift idea for a second baby is something that can be kept as a keepsake for years to come. This could include a handprint/footprint kit, photo album or frame, or even personalized jewelry with the baby’s birthstone.

5. Subscription Boxes

Subscription boxes are becoming increasingly popular as gifts for new parents. They offer curated products based on the age of your child and can be tailored specifically for second babies. These boxes often include essentials such as diapers and wipes as well as fun toys and books.

6.Donations in Baby’s Name

If you know someone who has everything they need for their second baby, consider making donations in the baby’s name to a charity or organization that is important to them. Not only does this make a meaningful gift but also teaches your children about giving back.

In conclusion, when buying gifts for a second baby think practicality and personalization while also considering thoughtful gestures towards older siblings or charitable donations in the baby’s name. With these recommendations in mind, you will surely find the perfect gift that will bring joy not only to the new addition but to the whole family.

Author Profile

Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell, a distinguished author celebrated for her engaging novels like "Slipping," "Little Blog on the Prairie," "I Remember You," and co-authoring "The Amanda Project," has a remarkable academic and creative background. She received her undergraduate degree from Barnard College and her Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from Columbia University, foundational experiences that have significantly shaped her literary career.

Living in Brooklyn, New York, with her family, Cathleen's life is as vibrant and textured as the narratives she weaves—rich with adventures that span from hiking the dramatic Italian coastline to crafting unique culinary creations, like her own pasta dish which she shares with readers upon request.

In 2024, Cathleen Davitt Bell expanded her repertoire by initiating a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This venture represents a natural progression of her narrative expertise into the realm of product critique, where she applies her descriptive and analytical skills to evaluate a variety of products.