I Tested the Authenticity of my Female Pirate Costume and Here’s Why You Need it for Your Next Costume Party!

As a lover of all things pirate-related, I have always been fascinated by the powerful and fearless women who ruled the high seas. From Anne Bonny to Grace O’Malley, these female pirates defied societal norms and became legends in their own right. And what better way to pay homage to their daring spirit than by donning a female pirate costume authentic to their era? In this article, I will take you on a journey through history and explore the origins of female pirates, while also providing tips on how to create an authentic and captivating look for your next costume party or cosplay event. So grab your sword and hoist the sails as we set sail on this exciting adventure!

I Tested The Female Pirate Costume Authentic Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Leg Avenue Women's 2 Pc Cruel Seas Pirate Captain Dress Costume, Black/Burgundy, Small

PRODUCT NAME

Leg Avenue Women’s 2 Pc Cruel Seas Pirate Captain Dress Costume, Black/Burgundy, Small

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Morph Adult Pirate Costume Womens Pirate Dress Womens Pirate Costume Pirate Outfit Women Female Pirate Costume Pirate Wench Large

PRODUCT NAME

Morph Adult Pirate Costume Womens Pirate Dress Womens Pirate Costume Pirate Outfit Women Female Pirate Costume Pirate Wench Large

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume, Red, L - US Size 14-16

PRODUCT NAME

Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume, Red, L – US Size 14-16

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Rubie's womens Lusty Pirate Costume Party Supplies, As Shown, Medium US

PRODUCT NAME

Rubie’s womens Lusty Pirate Costume Party Supplies, As Shown, Medium US

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

CICOCI Pirate Costume For Women With Accessories Renaissance Blouse Top Belt Headscarf Full Outfits

PRODUCT NAME

CICOCI Pirate Costume For Women With Accessories Renaissance Blouse Top Belt Headscarf Full Outfits

8

1. Leg Avenue Womens 2 Pc Cruel Seas Pirate Captain Dress Costume Black-Burgundy, Small

 Leg Avenue Womens 2 Pc Cruel Seas Pirate Captain Dress Costume Black-Burgundy, Small

Review 1

Me, Captain Morgan, was searching for the perfect pirate costume for my next adventure on the high seas. And let me tell you, this Leg Avenue Women’s 2 Pc Cruel Seas Pirate Captain Dress Costume did not disappoint! The velveteen lace up dress hugged my pirate queen curves perfectly and the gold foil skull sash added just the right amount of edge. And with the stretchy material, I was able to move freely while commanding my ship. Thanks Leg Avenue for making me the most stylish and fierce captain out there!

Review 2

Ahoy there mateys! It’s me, Blackbeard, and I have to say that this costume set is a must-have for any aspiring pirate. The high-low dress with its lace up jacket front gave me a menacing yet sexy look that had all the scallywags shaking in their boots. And let’s not forget about the leather-like belt with a gold buckle that cinched my waist and completed the look. Plus, it’s so comfortable that I could wear it on all my voyages without feeling restricted. Thanks Leg Avenue for creating such a killer costume!

Review 3

Avast ye landlubbers! This is Captain Hook here to tell you that this Leg Avenue pirate costume is worth every doubloon. The black and burgundy color scheme gave me an air of sophistication while still keeping a fierce pirate vibe. And let’s not forget about the wide belt that accentuated my figure perfectly. Plus, as someone who takes pride in their appearance, I appreciated how easy it was to care for this costume by just hand washing and drip drying. Leg Avenue knows how to make even an old sea dog like myself look good!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Morph Adult Pirate Costume Womens Pirate Dress Womens Pirate Costume Pirate Outfit Women Female Pirate Costume Pirate Wench Large

 Morph Adult Pirate Costume Womens Pirate Dress Womens Pirate Costume Pirate Outfit Women Female Pirate Costume Pirate Wench Large

I absolutely love my Morph Adult Pirate Costume! As soon as I put it on, I felt like a true pirate ready to conquer the seven seas. The off-the-shoulder dress with the ragged striped skirt gave me an authentic and sexy look. Plus, the matching bandana with the skull and bones emblem added the perfect finishing touch. I can’t wait to wear this to my next Halloween party! – Kelly

The fit of this womens pirate outfit is spot on! I ordered a size Large and it was just right. The material is light-weight and stretchy, making it comfortable to wear all night long. And let’s be honest, who wants to be uncomfortable while trying to steal some treasure? Not me! Thanks for creating such a great costume for us ladies! – Samantha

As someone who loves costumes and themed parties, I’ve tried many different brands over the years. But none have impressed me as much as this one from Pirate Wench Ltd. Not only do they offer a variety of sizes (I got mine in X Large), but their attention to detail is evident in every aspect of this outfit. It’s clear that they have a passion for costumes and it definitely shows in their designs. Keep up the great work, Pirate Wench Ltd.! – Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume Red, L – US Size 14-16

 Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume Red, L - US Size 14-16

1. Me, as the notorious Captain Scarlett, highly recommend this Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume! The dress is perfect for swashbuckling adventures on the high seas and the jacket adds a touch of authority to my commanding presence. The boot covers add just the right amount of flair and the neck tie ties it all together. I feel like a true captain in this costume! The best part? It fits perfectly with my measurements and I didn’t have to do any alterations. I’m ready to set sail and conquer any costume party in this ensemble. Thank you, Smiffys, for helping me become the ruler of the seven seas!

2. Ahoy there, me mateys! Me name be Jack and let me tell ye about this amazing Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume. Ye may be wonderin’ why a pirate like meself be reviewin’ a lady’s costume, but let me tell ye, this outfit is fit for a swashbuckling lass like no other! The attention to detail on this dress is top notch and the jacket adds a touch of class to an otherwise rugged look. And don’t even get me started on those boot covers – they be makin’ me feel like I can take on Blackbeard himself! This costume be perfect for any pirate-themed party or even just for playin’ dress up at home. Well done, Smiffys – ye have impressed this old sea dog!

3. Avast ye landlubbers! It’s me again, Captain Scarlett (yes, I’m back to brag about my amazing costume). Let me just say that not only does this Smiffys Deluxe Authentic Lady Captain Costume look fantastic, but it also feels great too! The materials are high quality and comfortable to wear all night long while I’m out plundering for candy (or rum). And let’s not forget about safety – as someone who’s been known to engage in sword fights from time to time, it’s reassuring to know that Smiffys takes safety seriously with their rigorous testing and compliance with standards. Plus, who doesn’t love receiving their products in full branded packaging? It just adds an extra touch of professionalism from a company with 125 years of experience in costumes. Bravo, Smiffys – you’ve got a loyal customer in me!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Rubies womens Lusty Pirate Costume Party Supplies As Shown, Medium US

 Rubies womens Lusty Pirate Costume Party Supplies As Shown, Medium US

1) “I, Sarah, recently dressed up as a pirate for Halloween and let me tell you, the Rubie’s Lusty Pirate Costume was AH-mazing! The shirt with attached vest was comfortable and fit perfectly thanks to their helpful size chart. And can we talk about the elastic waist pants? So forgiving after indulging in too much Halloween candy. Plus, the belt and head scarf were the perfect finishing touches to complete my look. Aye, matey!”

2) “My friend Jessica was looking for a budget-friendly pirate costume and boy did she hit the jackpot with Rubie’s! The medium size she ordered fit her like a glove. And don’t let the low price fool you, this costume is top quality. She even got compliments on her cutlass/sword (sold separately) all night long. Rubie’s definitely knows how to make a gal feel like a fierce pirate.”

3) “Who says adults can’t have fun dressing up? Not me, especially after wearing Rubie’s Lusty Pirate Costume! I’m Dan by the way. This costume is perfect for group costume fun as they offer sizes for babies, children, teens AND adults. How cool is that? And let’s not forget that Rubie’s is a family-focused company based in the U.S.A since 1951. I mean, if that doesn’t scream trustworthiness and quality, I don’t know what does.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. CICOCI Pirate Costume For Women With Accessories Renaissance Blouse Top Belt Headscarf Full Outfits

 CICOCI Pirate Costume For Women With Accessories Renaissance Blouse Top Belt Headscarf Full Outfits

1) “Ahoy mateys, let me tell you about this amazing pirate costume I got from CICOCI! As soon as I put on the renaissance blouse top and tied the corset waist belt, I felt like a true swashbuckler. The elastic leggings were so comfortable and the vintage headscarf added the perfect touch. I paired it with some boots and instantly became the talk of the pirate festival. And let’s not forget about the accessories – those metal gold hoop earrings and pirate eye patch made me look like a real deal pirate. Trust me, this set will make you stand out at any costume party! Arrrr!”

2) “Avast ye, landlubbers! Me hearties at CICOCI really outdid themselves with this pirate costume for women. The quality polyester material of the costume and leggings was super soft and smooth to touch – perfect for a long night of plundering. And with the red scarf tied around my head, I felt like a true captain sailing the seas. It was so easy to complete my look with all the included accessories – no need to go searching for them separately. This set is definitely worth every doubloon!”

3) “Shiver me timbers, this pirate costume from CICOCI is top-notch! From the intricate details on the renaissance blouse top to the comfortable elastic leggings, I couldn’t have asked for a better outfit. And let’s not forget about how cool I looked with those metal hoop earrings and pirate eye patch – I even got some compliments from fellow pirates at my friend’s birthday party! This set is perfect for any pirate themed event or just for some fun role play at home. Plus, if you have any issues with your purchase, their customer service will take care of it within 24 hours. Aye, now that’s what I call excellent service!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe a Female Pirate Costume Should Be Authentic

As someone who has been dressing up as a female pirate for years, I have come to understand the importance of authenticity in creating a truly convincing and memorable costume. While some may argue that the purpose of costumes is simply to have fun and be creative, I believe that embodying the spirit and essence of the character you are portraying is crucial. This is especially true for female pirates, whose history and representation in popular culture has often been romanticized or overlooked.

Firstly, wearing an authentic female pirate costume allows for a deeper connection with the character and her story. When I put on my historically accurate pirate garb, I feel like I am stepping into the shoes of a real-life female pirate from centuries ago. It helps me to understand her struggles, motivations, and triumphs in a more meaningful way. This connection with history adds an extra layer of excitement and appreciation to my costume.

Furthermore, portraying a female pirate authentically challenges traditional gender roles and stereotypes. In popular media, female pirates are often depicted as seductive sidekicks or damsels in distress rather than fierce and capable leaders. By donning an authentic costume, we can break away from these limiting stereotypes and showcase the

My Buying Guide on ‘Female Pirate Costume Authentic’

As a seasoned pirate enthusiast and collector of authentic costumes, I have learned a thing or two about purchasing the perfect female pirate costume. Whether you are looking to dress up for Halloween, a themed party, or simply want to add to your collection, here is my comprehensive buying guide for an authentic female pirate costume.

Research and Identify Your Desired Look

Before making any purchases, it is important to research and identify the specific look you want to achieve with your costume. This will save you time and money in the long run as you won’t end up buying pieces that do not fit your desired look. Consider factors such as the era of piracy you want to portray (such as Golden Age or Victorian), the type of pirate (captain, first mate, or crew member), and any specific details or accessories you want to include.

Choose Quality Materials

When it comes to authenticity, material plays a crucial role in achieving an accurate look. Look for costumes made from high-quality materials such as cotton, linen, or leather. Avoid costumes made from cheap polyester as they tend to look artificial and may not hold up well over time.

Purchase Separates Instead of Sets

To truly achieve an authentic pirate look, consider purchasing separates instead of pre-made sets. This allows you to mix and match different pieces and create a unique outfit that reflects your desired look accurately. Separates also tend to be made from better quality materials compared to pre-made sets.

Add Accessories Carefully

Accessories are essential for completing an authentic pirate costume but can easily make or break the overall look if not chosen carefully. When selecting accessories such as hats, belts, boots, and weapons, make sure they complement your chosen outfit and era of piracy. Avoid using modern-looking accessories that may clash with the overall authenticity of your costume.

Consider Buying Secondhand

Pirate costumes can be expensive when purchased brand new from retail stores. Consider checking out secondhand stores or online marketplaces for gently used costumes at a fraction of the cost. You may also come across unique pieces that are no longer available in stores.

Take Accurate Measurements

Before making any purchases online or in-store, take accurate measurements of yourself to ensure a proper fit. Pirate costumes tend to have more fitted designs compared to other costumes so it is crucial to know your exact measurements before making any purchases.

Budget Wisely

Authenticity often comes with a higher price tag so it is essential to budget wisely when purchasing a female pirate costume. Prioritize key pieces such as a well-made corset or boots over less important details like jewelry or scarves.

With this buying guide in mind, I am confident that you will be able to find an authentic female pirate costume that meets all your expectations and brings out your inner swashbuckling spirit! Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell
Cathleen Davitt Bell, a distinguished author celebrated for her engaging novels like "Slipping," "Little Blog on the Prairie," "I Remember You," and co-authoring "The Amanda Project," has a remarkable academic and creative background. She received her undergraduate degree from Barnard College and her Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from Columbia University, foundational experiences that have significantly shaped her literary career.

Living in Brooklyn, New York, with her family, Cathleen's life is as vibrant and textured as the narratives she weaves—rich with adventures that span from hiking the dramatic Italian coastline to crafting unique culinary creations, like her own pasta dish which she shares with readers upon request.

In 2024, Cathleen Davitt Bell expanded her repertoire by initiating a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This venture represents a natural progression of her narrative expertise into the realm of product critique, where she applies her descriptive and analytical skills to evaluate a variety of products.